Generative Compilation: On-the-Fly Compiler Feedback as AI Generates Code
Abstract
Languages with rich static semantics, such as Rust, provide stronger guarantees for AI-generated code, but their strictness makes generation more difficult. Off-the-shelf compilers can provide useful feedback post-generation, but does not guide intermediate generation steps, such as those during autoregressive LLM decoding. Constrained decoding intervenes earlier by rejecting invalid tokens during sampling, but requires white-box model access and costly reimplementation for semantic constraints.We introduce generative compilation, the first approach to obtaining compiler feedback on partial programs during generation. The core technical device is a sealor: a lightweight, mostly syntax-guided transformation that converts partial programs into complete ones that standard compilers can diagnose. It is designed such that possible-to-complete partial programs are never rejected, while preserving enough code context to catch genuine dead ends early. We construct such a sealor on a core Rust-like calculus and prove that it satisfies these properties, all mechanized in Lean. We extend it to the first partial-program checker for real Rust. We evaluate our method on challenging repository-level Rust coding tasks, across both frontier black-box and open-weight models. We show that generative compilation reduces non-compiling outputs and improves functional correctness, relative to standard post-generation feedback. It does so by detecting a broad range of errors close to their source and early during generation, thereby reducing errors cascades and enabling focused diagnostics. More broadly, generative compilation is a step toward making compilers a first-class citizen of AI-assisted programming active during generation, rather than a separate post-generation check.
Community
We introduce generative compilation, which provides LLMs with compiler feedback during code generation.
Its core device is a sealor: a lightweight, mostly syntax-guided transformation that closes a partial program so that an off-the-shelf compiler can diagnose it.
We formalize the properties for such a sealor to be correct and useful, mechanize a sealor for a core Rust calculus in Lean, and build the first partial-program checker for real Rust.
Across seven frontier and open-weight models on repository-level Rust translation and API-update tasks, generative compilation reduces non-compiling outputs from 20.7% with post-generation feedback to 13.1%, while improving average functional correctness from 59.5% to 63.0%.
It detects errors after a mean 33.3% of the file has been generated and returns substantially more focused diagnostics.
Models citing this paper 0
No model linking this paper
Datasets citing this paper 2
eth-sri/API-Upgrade
Spaces citing this paper 0
No Space linking this paper