# FPR_B manual review (plan §4.2) **Reviewer:** Andrés Mongui · **Prepared:** 2026-11-07 from `runs/20261104T232056Z_C2_experiment_check/results.jsonl` (read-only) · **Verdicts:** pending ## What to decide Baseline B (C2) solved each problem in natural language and then judged its own proof; it claimed all 30 `test` problems. Each claim was handed to the Autoformalizer–Verifier loop (`--check`: up to 3 attempts, same lemma search as C5, its own budget). For 11 claims no attempt was accepted by Lean, so FPR_B = 11/30 = 36.7 % is an **upper bound**: an unconfirmed claim may be a wrong argument, or a correct argument that the pipeline failed to formalise. The plan asks for a manual review of 10 of them. The 10 were drawn with `random.Random(2026).sample(sorted ids, 10)` (left out: `amc12a_2008_p15`). For each problem below, read C2's informal solution against the problem and mark **one** verdict: - **Wrong argument**: the informal solution has a mathematical error or gap that matters (wrong answer, missing case, unjustified key step). - **Formalisation failure**: the informal argument is correct (complete enough for a competition grader); the Lean attempts failed for other reasons. - **Cannot decide**: not enough information, or the argument is too sketchy to judge either way. Please base the verdict on the informal solution. The Lean errors and the line "proved by other configurations" are context only: a true statement can still have a wrong proof, and a Lean error is often about syntax or tactics rather than the mathematics. Attempt reasons: `lean:error` = Lean compiled the attempt and reported errors; `sanitize:empty` = the Autoformalizer returned no tactics (usually its output was cut at max_tokens); `sanitize:parse` = Lean's parser rejected the text before compiling. ## Summary (fill in) | # | Problem | Difficulty | Verdict | Short reason | |---|---|---|---|---| | 1 | `amc12b_2002_p3` | medium | | | | 2 | `imo_1964_p1_2` | hard | | | | 3 | `imo_1965_p2` | hard | | | | 4 | `imo_1978_p5` | hard | | | | 5 | `imo_1979_p1` | hard | | | | 6 | `imo_1984_p6` | hard | | | | 7 | `imo_1987_p6` | hard | | | | 8 | `imo_1993_p5` | hard | | | | 9 | `putnam_1965_b2` | hard | | | | 10 | `putnam_1995_b1` | hard | | | Totals: wrong argument __ · formalisation failure __ · cannot decide __ --- ## 1. `amc12b_2002_p3` (number_theory, medium) ### Problem (informal) For how many positive integers $n$ is $n^2 - 3n + 2$ a [[prime]] number? $\mathrm{(A)}\ \text{none} \qquad\mathrm{(B)}\ \text{one} \qquad\mathrm{(C)}\ \text{two} \qquad\mathrm{(D)}\ \text{more\ than\ two,\ but\ finitely\ many} \qquad\mathrm{(E)}\ \text{infinitely\ many}$ Show that it is \mathrm{(B)}\ \text{one}. ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem amc12b_2002_p3 (S : Finset ℕ) (h₀ : ∀ n : ℕ, n ∈ S ↔ 0 < n ∧ Nat.Prime (n ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * n)) : S.card = 1 := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Let P(n)=n^2-3n+2. Factor: \[P(n)=n^2-3n+2=(n-1)(n-2).\] For positive integers n, check the possible small cases directly: - If n=1, then P(1)=0, not prime. - If n=2, then P(2)=0, not prime. - If n=3, then P(3)=3^2-3\cdot 3+2=2, which is prime. Now suppose n\ge 4. Then n-2\ge 2 and n-1\ge 3, so both factors in \[(n-1)(n-2)\] are integers greater than 1. Hence P(n) is a product of two integers greater than 1, so it is composite, not prime. Thus the only positive integer n for which n^2-3n+2 is prime is n=3. Therefore exactly one such positive integer exists, so the answer is (B) one. **Final answer:** (B) one; the unique value is \(n=3\). **C2's self-assessment:** verdict `correct`, confidence 1.0; no issues noted (1 round(s)). ### Lean check attempts **Attempt 1:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 23: Type mismatch hn3 has type n = 3 but is expected to have type n ∈ {3} line 32: Application type mismatch: The argument hdvd has type m ∣ m * (m + 1) of sort `Prop` but is expected to have type ℕ of sort `Type` in the application Prime.eq_one_or_self_of_dvd hprime hdvd ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean rw [Finset.card_eq_one] use 3 ext n rw [h₀ n] constructor · rintro ⟨hpos, hprime⟩ have h12 : n = 1 ∨ n = 2 ∨ 3 ≤ n := by omega rcases h12 with rfl | rfl | hge · have h2 := hprime.two_le norm_num at h2 · have h2 := hprime.two_le norm_num at h2 · by_cases hn3 : n = 3 · exact hn3 · have hn4 : 4 ≤ n := by omega obtain ⟨m, rfl⟩ : ∃ m, n = m + 2 := ⟨n - 2, by omega⟩ have hm2 : 2 ≤ m := by omega have h_eq : (m + 2) ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * (m + 2) = m * (m + 1) := by apply Nat.sub_eq_of_eq_add ring rw [h_eq] at hprime have hdvd : m ∣ m * (m + 1) := dvd_mul_right m (m + 1) have hcases := hprime.eq_one_or_self_of_dvd hdvd rcases hcases with h1 | h2 · omega · nlinarith · intro hn simp only [Finset.mem_singleton] at hn rw [hn] norm_num ```
**Attempt 2:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 17: unsolved goals case «1» S : Finset ℕ h₀ : ∀ (n : ℕ), n ∈ S ↔ 0 < n ∧ Nat.Prime (n ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * n) n : ℕ hpos : 0 < 1 hprime : Nat.Prime (1 ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * 1) hlt : ¬3 ≤ 1 hle : 1 ≤ 2 ⊢ False case «2» S : Finset ℕ h₀ : ∀ (n : ℕ), n ∈ S ↔ 0 < n ∧ Nat.Prime (n ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * n) n : ℕ hpos : 0 < 2 hprime ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 2 ```lean rw [Finset.card_eq_one] use 3 ext n rw [h₀ n] simp only [Finset.mem_singleton] constructor · rintro ⟨hpos, hprime⟩ have hge3 : 3 ≤ n := by by_contra hlt have hle : n ≤ 2 := by omega interval_cases n <;> try omega <;> norm_num at hprime by_cases hn3 : n = 3 · exact hn3 · have hn4 : 4 ≤ n := by omega obtain ⟨m, hm⟩ : ∃ m, n = m + 4 := ⟨n - 4, by omega⟩ rw [hm] at hprime ⊢ have h_eq : (m + 4) ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * (m + 4) = (m + 2) * (m + 3) := by apply Nat.sub_eq_of_eq_add ring rw [h_eq] at hprime have hdvd : (m + 2) ∣ (m + 2) * (m + 3) := dvd_mul_right (m + 2) (m + 3) have hcases := hprime.eq_one_or_self_of_dvd (m + 2) hdvd rcases hcases with h1 | h1 · omega · have hm2 : 0 < m + 2 := by omega nlinarith [mul_pos hm2 hm2] · intro hn rw [hn] norm_num ```
**Attempt 3:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 41: Application type mismatch: The argument fun a => amc12b_2002_p3_sg1._proof_6 n hn3 a has type n - 1 ≠ 0 but is expected to have type 0 < n - 1 in the application Nat.eq_of_mul_eq_mul_left fun a => amc12b_2002_p3_sg1._proof_6 n hn3 a ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean rw [Finset.card_eq_one] use 3 ext n rw [h₀ n] simp only [Finset.mem_singleton] constructor · rintro ⟨hpos, hprime⟩ have hn3 : 3 ≤ n := by by_contra hlt have hle : n ≤ 2 := by omega have hn : n = 1 ∨ n = 2 := by omega rcases hn with rfl | rfl · have h1 : 1 ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * 1 = 0 := by norm_num rw [h1] at hprime exact Nat.not_prime_zero hprime · have h2 : 2 ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * 2 = 0 := by norm_num rw [h2] at hprime exact Nat.not_prime_zero hprime have h1 : 1 ≤ n := by omega have h2 : 2 ≤ n := by omega have h_eq : n ^ 2 + 2 - 3 * n = (n - 1) * (n - 2) := by apply Nat.sub_eq_of_eq_add nlinarith [Nat.sub_add_cancel h1, Nat.sub_add_cancel h2] rw [h_eq] at hprime have hdvd : (n - 1) ∣ (n - 1) * (n - 2) := dvd_mul_right (n - 1) (n - 2) have hcases := hprime.eq_one_or_self_of_dvd (n - 1) hdvd rcases hcases with h1' | h1' · omega · have hmul : (n - 1) * 1 = (n - 1) * (n - 2) := by rw [Nat.mul_one] exact h1' have h21 : 1 = n - 2 := Nat.eq_of_mul_eq_mul_left (by omega : n - 1 ≠ 0) hmul omega · intro hn rw [hn] norm_num ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: C3, C4, C5. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 2. `imo_1964_p1_2` (number_theory, hard) ### Problem (informal) Show that for any natural number $n$, $7$ does not divide $2^n + 1$. ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem imo_1964_p1_2 (n : ℕ) : ¬7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Work modulo 7. We compute the powers of 2 modulo 7: 2^0 ≡ 1, 2^1 ≡ 2, 2^2 ≡ 4, 2^3 ≡ 8 ≡ 1. Thus the residues of 2^n modulo 7 repeat with period 3, and are always one of 1, 2, or 4. Hence 2^n + 1 is congruent modulo 7 to one of 1+1=2, 2+1=3, or 4+1=5. None of these is congruent to 0 modulo 7. Therefore 7 can never divide 2^n+1 for any natural number n. **Final answer:** For every natural number n, 7 does not divide 2^n+1. **C2's self-assessment:** verdict `correct`, confidence 1.0; no issues noted (1 round(s)). ### Lean check attempts **Attempt 1:** `lean:error` (class `missing_lemma`) ```text line 13: Unknown constant `ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd` line 16: unsolved goals n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 hz : 2 ^ n + 1 = 0 ⊢ 8 = 1 line 22: unsolved goals n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 hz : 2 ^ n + 1 = 0 h3 : 2 ^ 3 = 1 hn : n = 3 * (n / 3) + n % 3 ⊢ 2 ^ (3 * (n / 3) + n % 3) = 2 ^ (3 * ((3 * (n / 3) + n % 3) / 3) + (3 * (n / 3) + n % 3) % 3) ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean intro h have hz : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ n + 1 = 0 := by have h0 : ((2 ^ n + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod 7) = 0 := (ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd (2 ^ n + 1)).2 h push_cast at h0 exact h0 have h3 : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ 3 = 1 := by norm_num have hpow : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ n = (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by have hn : n = 3 * (n / 3) + n % 3 := by have hdiv := Nat.div_add_mod n 3 omega calc (2 : ZMod 7) ^ n = (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (3 * (n / 3) + n % 3) := by rw [hn] _ = (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (3 * (n / 3)) * (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by rw [pow_add] _ = ((2 : ZMod 7) ^ 3) ^ (n / 3) * (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by rw [pow_mul] _ = 1 ^ (n / 3) * (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by rw [h3] _ = (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by simp rw [hpow] at hz set k := n % 3 with hk have hklt : k < 3 := by have hlt : n % 3 < 3 := Nat.mod_lt n (by norm_num) omega interval_cases k <;> norm_num at hz ```
**Attempt 2:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 37: Tactic `rewrite` failed: Did not find an occurrence of the pattern ↑?a = 0 in the target expression ↑2 ≠ 0 n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 h0 : 2 ^ (n % 3) + 1 = 0 h3 : 2 ^ 3 = 1 hpow : 2 ^ n = 2 ^ (n % 3) ⊢ ↑2 ≠ 0 line 40: Tactic `rewrite` failed: Did not find an occurrence of the pattern ↑?a = 0 in the target expression ↑3 ≠ 0 n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 h0 : 2 ^ (n % 3) + 1 = 0 h3 : 2 ^ 3 = 1 hpow : 2 ^ n = 2 ^ (n % 3) h2 : ↑2 ≠ 0 ⊢ ↑3 ≠ 0 line 43: Tactic `rewrite` failed: Did not find an occurrence of the pattern ↑?a = 0 in the target expression ↑5 ≠ 0 n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 h0 : 2 ^ (n % 3) + 1 = 0 h3 : 2 ^ 3 = 1 hpow : 2 ^ n = 2 ^ (n % 3) h2 : ↑2 ≠ 0 h3n : ↑3 ≠ 0 ⊢ ↑5 ≠ 0 ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 2 ```lean intro h have h0 : ((2 ^ n + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod 7) = 0 := by have hz : (((2 ^ n + 1 : ℕ) : ℤ) : ZMod 7) = 0 := by rw [ZMod.intCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] exact_mod_cast h simpa using hz push_cast at h0 have h3 : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ 3 = 1 := by have h8 : ((8 : ℤ) : ZMod 7) = ((1 : ℤ) : ZMod 7) := by rw [ZMod.intCast_eq_intCast_iff_dvd_sub] norm_num calc (2 : ZMod 7) ^ 3 = ((8 : ℤ) : ZMod 7) := by push_cast ring _ = ((1 : ℤ) : ZMod 7) := h8 _ = 1 := by push_cast rfl have hpow : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ n = (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by have hn : n = 3 * (n / 3) + n % 3 := by have := Nat.div_add_mod n 3 omega conv_lhs => rw [hn] rw [pow_add, pow_mul, h3, one_pow, one_mul] rw [hpow] at h0 have h2 : ((2 : ℕ) : ZMod 7) ≠ 0 := by rw [ZMod.natCast_eq_zero_iff] norm_num have h3n : ((3 : ℕ) : ZMod 7) ≠ 0 := by rw [ZMod.natCast_eq_zero_iff] norm_num have h5n : ((5 : ℕ) : ZMod 7) ≠ 0 := by rw [ZMod.natCast_eq_zero_iff] norm_num have hcases : n % 3 = 0 ∨ n % 3 = 1 ∨ n % 3 = 2 := by have hlt : n % 3 < 3 := Nat.mod_lt n (by norm_num) omega rcases hcases with hc | hc | hc · rw [hc] at h0 norm_num at h0 exact h2 (by simpa using h0) · rw [hc] at h0 norm_num at h0 exact h3n (by simpa using h0) · rw [hc] at h0 norm_num at h0 exact h5n (by simpa using h0) ```
**Attempt 3:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 11: Invalid projection: Projections cannot be used on functions, and ZMod.natCast_eq_zero_iff has function type `∀ (a b : ℕ), ↑a = 0 ↔ b ∣ a` line 13: unsolved goals n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 h0 : 2 ^ n + 1 = 0 ⊢ 8 = 1 line 23: unsolved goals n : ℕ h : 7 ∣ 2 ^ n + 1 h0 : 2 ^ 0 + 1 = 0 h3 : 2 ^ 3 = 1 hpow : 2 ^ n = 2 ^ (n % 3) hc : n % 3 = 0 ⊢ ¬2 = 0 ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean intro h have h0 : ((2 ^ n + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod 7) = 0 := (ZMod.natCast_eq_zero_iff).2 h push_cast at h0 have h3 : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ 3 = 1 := by norm_num have hpow : (2 : ZMod 7) ^ n = (2 : ZMod 7) ^ (n % 3) := by conv_lhs => rw [← Nat.div_add_mod n 3] rw [pow_add, pow_mul, h3, one_pow, one_mul] rw [hpow] at h0 have hcases : n % 3 = 0 ∨ n % 3 = 1 ∨ n % 3 = 2 := by have hlt : n % 3 < 3 := Nat.mod_lt _ (by norm_num) omega rcases hcases with hc | hc | hc · rw [hc] at h0 exact absurd h0 (by norm_num) · rw [hc] at h0 exact absurd h0 (by norm_num) · rw [hc] at h0 exact absurd h0 (by norm_num) ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: C1, C3, C5. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 3. `imo_1965_p2` (algebra, hard) ### Problem (informal) Consider the system of equations $a_{11}x_1 + a_{12}x_2 + a_{13}x_3 = 0$ $a_{21}x_1 + a_{22}x_2 + a_{23}x_3 = 0$ $a_{31}x_1 + a_{32}x_2 + a_{33}x_3 = 0$ with unknowns $x_1$, $x_2$, $x_3$. The coefficients satisfy the conditions: (a) $a_{11}$, $a_{22}$, $a_{33}$ are positive numbers; (b) the remaining coefficients are negative numbers; (c) in each equation, the sum of the coefficients is positive. Prove that the given system has only the solution $x_1 = x_2 = x_3 = 0$. ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem imo_1965_p2 (x y z : ℝ) (a : ℕ → ℝ) (h₀ : 0 < a 0 ∧ 0 < a 4 ∧ 0 < a 8) (h₁ : a 1 < 0 ∧ a 2 < 0) (h₂ : a 3 < 0 ∧ a 5 < 0) (h₃ : a 6 < 0 ∧ a 7 < 0) (h₄ : 0 < a 0 + a 1 + a 2) (h₅ : 0 < a 3 + a 4 + a 5) (h₆ : 0 < a 6 + a 7 + a 8) (h₇ : a 0 * x + a 1 * y + a 2 * z = 0) (h₈ : a 3 * x + a 4 * y + a 5 * z = 0) (h₉ : a 6 * x + a 7 * y + a 8 * z = 0) : x = 0 ∧ y = 0 ∧ z = 0 := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Suppose, for contradiction, that the system has a nonzero solution \((x_1,x_2,x_3)\). Let \(M=\max\{|x_1|,|x_2|,|x_3|\}>0\), and choose an index \(k\in\{1,2,3\}\) such that \(|x_k|=M\). Write the \(k\)-th equation as \[ a_{kk}x_k=-\sum_{j\ne k} a_{kj}x_j. \] Taking absolute values gives \[ a_{kk}|x_k|=\left|\sum_{j\ne k} a_{kj}x_j\right|\le \sum_{j\ne k}|a_{kj}|\,|x_j|. \] Because the off-diagonal coefficients are negative, \(|a_{kj}|=-a_{kj}\) for \(j\ne k\). Also, since \(|x_j|\le M=|x_k|\), we obtain \[ a_{kk}|x_k|\le \left(\sum_{j\ne k}(-a_{kj})\right)|x_k|. \] However, condition (c) for the \(k\)-th equation says \[ a_{k1}+a_{k2}+a_{k3}>0. \] Since \(a_{kk}>0\) and the other two coefficients are negative, this is equivalent to \[ a_{kk}>-\sum_{j\ne k}a_{kj}=\sum_{j\ne k}|a_{kj}|. \] Multiplying by \(|x_k|=M>0\) gives \[ a_{kk}|x_k|> \left(\sum_{j\ne k}|a_{kj}|\right)|x_k|, \] contradicting the previous inequality. Therefore no nonzero solution can exist, so necessarily \(x_1=x_2=x_3=0\). **Final answer:** The system has only the trivial solution \(x_1=x_2=x_3=0\). **C2's self-assessment:** verdict `correct`, confidence 0.99; no issues noted (1 round(s)). ### Lean check attempts **Attempt 1:** `lean:error` (class `missing_lemma`) ```text line 19: Unknown identifier `abs_add` line 22: No goals to be solved ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean have key : ∀ (p q r u v w : ℝ), 0 < p → q < 0 → r < 0 → 0 < p + q + r → p * u + q * v + r * w = 0 → |v| ≤ |u| → |w| ≤ |u| → u = 0 := by intro p q r u v w hp hq hr hsum heq hv hw have hM_nonneg : 0 ≤ |u| := abs_nonneg u have htri : p * |u| ≤ (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| := by rw [show p * |u| = |p * u| by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_pos hp]] have hpu : p * u = -(q * v + r * w) := by linarith rw [hpu, abs_neg] calc |q * v + r * w| ≤ |q * v| + |r * w| := abs_add _ _ _ = (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_mul, abs_of_neg hq, abs_of_neg hr] ring have hmono : (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| ≤ (-q + -r) * |u| := by have hq' : 0 ≤ -q := by linarith have hr' : 0 ≤ -r := by linarith have hv' : (-q) * |v| ≤ (-q) * |u| := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hv hq' have hw' : (-r) * |w| ≤ (-r) * |u| := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hw hr' linarith have hkey : p * |u| ≤ (-q + -r) * |u| := by linarith have hlt : (-q + -r) < p := by linarith have hMzero : |u| = 0 := by have hpos : 0 < p - (-q + -r) := by linarith nlinarith [hkey, hpos, hM_nonneg] exact abs_eq_zero.mp hMzero rcases le_total |x| |y| with hxy | hyx · rcases le_total |y| |z| with hyz | hzy · have hxz : |x| ≤ |z| := le_trans hxy hyz have hz0 : z = 0 := key (a 8) (a 6) (a 7) z x y h₀.2.2 h₃.1 h₃.2 (by linarith [h₆]) (by linarith [h₉]) hxz hyz have hzabs : |z| = 0 := by rw [hz0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · have hy0 : y = 0 := key (a 4) (a 3) (a 5) y x z h₀.2.1 h₂.1 h₂.2 (by linarith [h₅]) (by linarith [h₈]) hxy hzy have hyabs : |y| = 0 := by rw [hy0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxy, hyabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hz0 : z = 0 := by have : |z| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hzy, hyabs]) (abs_nonneg z) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · rcases le_total |x| |z| with hxz | hzx · have hyz : |y| ≤ |z| := le_trans hyx hxz have hz0 : z = 0 := key (a 8) (a 6) (a 7) z x y h₀.2.2 h₃.1 h₃.2 (by linarith [h₆]) (by linarith [h₉]) hxz hyz have hzabs : |z| = 0 := by rw [hz0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · have hx0 : x = 0 := key (a 0) (a 1) (a 2) x y z h₀.1 h₁.1 h₁.2 h₄ h₇ hyx hzx have hxabs : |x| = 0 := by rw [hx0, abs_zero] have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyx, hxabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hz0 : z = 0 := by have : |z| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hzx, hxabs]) (abs_nonneg z) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ ```
**Attempt 2:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 23: Type mismatch abs_add' ?m.573 ?m.574 has type |?m.573| ≤ |?m.574| + |?m.574 + ?m.573| but is expected to have type |q * v + r * w| ≤ |q * v| + |r * w| ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 2 ```lean have key : ∀ (p q r u v w : ℝ), 0 < p → q < 0 → r < 0 → 0 < p + q + r → p * u + q * v + r * w = 0 → |v| ≤ |u| → |w| ≤ |u| → u = 0 := by intro p q r u v w hp hq hr hsum heq hv hw have hM_nonneg : 0 ≤ |u| := abs_nonneg u have htri : p * |u| ≤ (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| := by have ha : |p * u| = p * |u| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_pos hp] have hpu : p * u = -(q * v + r * w) := by linarith have h1 : |q * v| = (-q) * |v| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_neg hq] have h2 : |r * w| = (-r) * |w| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_neg hr] calc p * |u| = |p * u| := ha.symm _ = |-(q * v + r * w)| := by rw [hpu] _ = |q * v + r * w| := abs_neg _ _ ≤ |q * v| + |r * w| := abs_add' _ _ _ = (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| := by rw [h1, h2] have hmono : (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| ≤ (-q + -r) * |u| := by have hq' : 0 ≤ -q := by linarith have hr' : 0 ≤ -r := by linarith have hv' : (-q) * |v| ≤ (-q) * |u| := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hv hq' have hw' : (-r) * |w| ≤ (-r) * |u| := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hw hr' linarith have hkey : p * |u| ≤ (-q + -r) * |u| := by linarith have hMzero : |u| = 0 := by have hpos : 0 < p - (-q + -r) := by linarith nlinarith [hkey, hpos, hM_nonneg] exact abs_eq_zero.mp hMzero rcases le_total |x| |y| with hxy | hyx · rcases le_total |y| |z| with hyz | hzy · have hxz : |x| ≤ |z| := le_trans hxy hyz have hz0 : z = 0 := key (a 8) (a 6) (a 7) z x y h₀.2.2 h₃.1 h₃.2 (by linarith [h₆]) (by linarith [h₉]) hxz hyz have hzabs : |z| = 0 := by rw [hz0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · have hy0 : y = 0 := key (a 4) (a 3) (a 5) y x z h₀.2.1 h₂.1 h₂.2 (by linarith [h₅]) (by linarith [h₈]) hxy hzy have hyabs : |y| = 0 := by rw [hy0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxy, hyabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hz0 : z = 0 := by have : |z| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hzy, hyabs]) (abs_nonneg z) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · rcases le_total |x| |z| with hxz | hzx · have hyz : |y| ≤ |z| := le_trans hyx hxz have hz0 : z = 0 := key (a 8) (a 6) (a 7) z x y h₀.2.2 h₃.1 h₃.2 (by linarith [h₆]) (by linarith [h₉]) hxz hyz have hzabs : |z| = 0 := by rw [hz0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · have hx0 : x = 0 := key (a 0) (a 1) (a 2) x y z h₀.1 h₁.1 h₁.2 h₄ h₇ hyx hzx have hxabs : |x| = 0 := by rw [hx0, abs_zero] have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyx, hxabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hz0 : z = 0 := by have : |z| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hzx, hxabs]) (abs_nonneg z) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ ```
**Attempt 3:** `lean:error` (class `missing_lemma`) ```text line 23: Unknown identifier `abs_add` ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean have key : ∀ (p q r u v w : ℝ), 0 < p → q < 0 → r < 0 → 0 < p + q + r → p * u + q * v + r * w = 0 → |v| ≤ |u| → |w| ≤ |u| → u = 0 := by intro p q r u v w hp hq hr hsum heq hv hw have hM_nonneg : 0 ≤ |u| := abs_nonneg u have htri : p * |u| ≤ (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| := by have ha : |p * u| = p * |u| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_pos hp] have hpu : p * u = -(q * v + r * w) := by linarith have h1 : |q * v| = (-q) * |v| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_neg hq] have h2 : |r * w| = (-r) * |w| := by rw [abs_mul, abs_of_neg hr] calc p * |u| = |p * u| := ha.symm _ = |-(q * v + r * w)| := by rw [hpu] _ = |q * v + r * w| := abs_neg _ _ ≤ |q * v| + |r * w| := abs_add _ _ _ = (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| := by rw [h1, h2] have hmono : (-q) * |v| + (-r) * |w| ≤ (-q + -r) * |u| := by have hq' : 0 ≤ -q := by linarith have hr' : 0 ≤ -r := by linarith have hv' : (-q) * |v| ≤ (-q) * |u| := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hv hq' have hw' : (-r) * |w| ≤ (-r) * |u| := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hw hr' linarith have hkey : p * |u| ≤ (-q + -r) * |u| := by linarith have hMzero : |u| = 0 := by have hpos : 0 < p - (-q + -r) := by linarith nlinarith [hkey, hpos, hM_nonneg] exact abs_eq_zero.mp hMzero rcases le_total |x| |y| with hxy | hyx · rcases le_total |y| |z| with hyz | hzy · have hxz : |x| ≤ |z| := le_trans hxy hyz have hz0 : z = 0 := key (a 8) (a 6) (a 7) z x y h₀.2.2 h₃.1 h₃.2 (by linarith [h₆]) (by linarith [h₉]) hxz hyz have hzabs : |z| = 0 := by rw [hz0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · have hy0 : y = 0 := key (a 4) (a 3) (a 5) y x z h₀.2.1 h₂.1 h₂.2 (by linarith [h₅]) (by linarith [h₈]) hxy hzy have hyabs : |y| = 0 := by rw [hy0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxy, hyabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hz0 : z = 0 := by have : |z| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hzy, hyabs]) (abs_nonneg z) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · rcases le_total |x| |z| with hxz | hzx · have hyz : |y| ≤ |z| := le_trans hyx hxz have hz0 : z = 0 := key (a 8) (a 6) (a 7) z x y h₀.2.2 h₃.1 h₃.2 (by linarith [h₆]) (by linarith [h₉]) hxz hyz have hzabs : |z| = 0 := by rw [hz0, abs_zero] have hx0 : x = 0 := by have : |x| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hxz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg x) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyz, hzabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ · have hx0 : x = 0 := key (a 0) (a 1) (a 2) x y z h₀.1 h₁.1 h₁.2 h₄ h₇ hyx hzx have hxabs : |x| = 0 := by rw [hx0, abs_zero] have hy0 : y = 0 := by have : |y| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hyx, hxabs]) (abs_nonneg y) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this have hz0 : z = 0 := by have : |z| = 0 := le_antisymm (by linarith [hzx, hxabs]) (abs_nonneg z) exact abs_eq_zero.mp this exact ⟨hx0, hy0, hz0⟩ ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: C1, C3, C5. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 4. `imo_1978_p5` (algebra, hard) ### Problem (informal) Let $f$ be an injective function from ${1,2,3,\ldots}$ in itself. Prove that for any $n$ we have: $\sum_{k=1}^{n} f(k)k^{-2} \geq \sum_{k=1}^{n} k^{-1}.$ ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem imo_1978_p5 (n : ℕ) (a : ℕ → ℕ) (h₀ : Function.Injective a) (h₁ : a 0 = 0) (h₂ : 0 < n) : (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 n, (1 : ℝ) / k) ≤ ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 n, (a k : ℝ) / k ^ 2 := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Let n be a positive integer. The numbers f(1),...,f(n) are distinct positive integers. Arrange them in increasing order as \[b_1Lean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean exact IMO1979P1.imo_1979_p1 p q h₀ h₁ ``` **Attempt 2:** `lean:error` (class `syntax`) ```text line 22: Tactic `rewrite` failed: Did not find an occurrence of the pattern ∏ x ∈ ?m.168, ?m.167 x ≠ 0 in the target expression ¬∏ i ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, ↑i = 0 p q : ℕ h₀ : 0 < q h₁ : ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, (-1) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / ↑k) = ↑p / ↑q D : ℕ := ∏ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, k N : ℤ := ∑ k ∈ Finset. line 29: failed to synthesize instance of type class Preorder (ZMod 1979) Hint: Type class instance resolution failures can be inspected with the `set_option trace.Meta.synthInstance true` command. line 29: failed to synthesize instance of type class LocallyFiniteOrder (ZMod 1979) Hint: Type class instance resolution failures can be inspected with the `set_option trace.Meta.synthInstance true` command. ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 2 ```lean let D : ℕ := ∏ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, k let N : ℤ := ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, (-1 : ℤ) ^ (k + 1) * (D / k : ℕ) have hDpos : 0 < D := by dsimp [D] rw [Nat.pos_iff_ne_zero] rw [Finset.prod_ne_zero_iff] intro k hk rw [Finset.mem_Icc] at hk omega have hDmod : (D : ZMod 1979) ≠ 0 := by dsimp [D] rw [Nat.cast_prod] rw [Finset.prod_ne_zero_iff] intro k hk rw [Finset.mem_Icc] at hk rw [ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] intro hdvd have hle : 1979 ≤ k := Nat.le_of_dvd (by omega) hdvd omega have hsum : (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, (-1 : ZMod 1979) ^ (k + 1) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹) = 0 := by decide have hNmod : (N : ZMod 1979) = 0 := by dsimp [N] push_cast have hDk : ∀ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979) = (D : ZMod 1979) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹ := by intro k hk rw [Finset.mem_Icc] at hk have hkpos : 0 < k := by omega have hkdvd : k ∣ D := by dsimp [D] exact Finset.dvd_prod_of_mem (fun x => x) hk have hk0 : (k : ZMod 1979) ≠ 0 := by rw [ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] intro hdvd have hle : 1979 ≤ k := Nat.le_of_dvd hkpos hdvd omega have hDeq : k * (D / k) = D := by rw [mul_comm] exact Nat.div_mul_cancel hkdvd have hcastDeq : (D : ZMod 1979) = (k : ZMod 1979) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979) := by rw [← hDeq] push_cast ring calc ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979) = (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹ * ((k : ZMod 1979) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979)) := by ```
**Attempt 3:** `lean:error` (class `syntax`) ```text line 24: Unknown constant `ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd` line 40: Unknown constant `ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd` line 47: unsolved goals p q : ℕ h₀ : 0 < q h₁ : ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, (-1) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / ↑k) = ↑p / ↑q hprime_fact : Fact (Nat.Prime 1979) D : ℕ := ∏ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, k N : ℤ := ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319, (-1) ^ (k + 1) * ↑(D / k) hDpos : 0 < D hDmod : ↑D ≠ 0 k : ℕ hk : k ∈ Finset.Icc 1 1319 hkdvd ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean haveI hprime_fact : Fact (Nat.Prime 1979) := ⟨by norm_num⟩ let D : ℕ := ∏ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, k let N : ℤ := ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℤ) ^ (k + 1) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ℤ) have hDpos : 0 < D := by dsimp [D] apply Finset.prod_pos intro k hk have hk1 := (Finset.mem_Icc.mp hk).1 omega have hDmod : (D : ZMod 1979) ≠ 0 := by dsimp [D] push_cast apply Finset.prod_ne_zero_iff.mpr intro k hk rw [ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] intro hdvd have hk1 := (Finset.mem_Icc.mp hk).1 have hk2 := (Finset.mem_Icc.mp hk).2 have hle : 1979 ≤ k := Nat.le_of_dvd (by omega) hdvd omega have hDkZ : ∀ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979) = (D : ZMod 1979) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹ := by intro k hk have hkdvd : k ∣ D := by dsimp [D] exact Finset.dvd_prod_of_mem (fun x => x) hk have hkpos : 0 < k := by have hk1 := (Finset.mem_Icc.mp hk).1 omega have hk0 : (k : ZMod 1979) ≠ 0 := by rw [ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] intro hdvd have hle : 1979 ≤ k := Nat.le_of_dvd hkpos hdvd have hk2 := (Finset.mem_Icc.mp hk).2 omega have hDeq : k * (D / k) = D := by rw [mul_comm, Nat.div_mul_cancel hkdvd] have hcast : (k : ZMod 1979) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979) = (D : ZMod 1979) := by rw [← hDeq] push_cast ring calc ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979) = (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹ * ((k : ZMod 1979) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979)) := by rw [inv_mul_cancel_left₀ hk0] _ = (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹ * (D : ZMod 1979) := by rw [hcast] _ = (D : ZMod 1979) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹ := by ring have hsum : (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ZMod 1979) ^ (k + 1) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹) = 0 := by decide have hNmod : (N : ZMod 1979) = 0 := by dsimp [N] push_cast calc (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ZMod 1979) ^ (k + 1) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ZMod 1979)) = ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (D : ZMod 1979) * ((-1 : ZMod 1979) ^ (k + 1) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro k hk rw [hDkZ k hk] ring _ = (D : ZMod 1979) * (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ZMod 1979) ^ (k + 1) * (k : ZMod 1979)⁻¹) := by rw [Finset.mul_sum] _ = (D : ZMod 1979) * 0 := by rw [hsum] _ = 0 := by rw [mul_zero] have hDkQ : ∀ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (1 / (k : ℚ)) * (D : ℚ) = ((D / k : ℕ) : ℚ) := by intro k hk have hkdvd : k ∣ D := by dsimp [D] exact Finset.dvd_prod_of_mem (fun x => x) hk have hkpos : 0 < k := by have hk1 := (Finset.mem_Icc.mp hk).1 omega have hDeq : k * (D / k) = D := by rw [mul_comm, Nat.div_mul_cancel hkdvd] have hcast : (k : ℚ) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ℚ) = (D : ℚ) := by rw [← hDeq] push_cast ring rw [← hcast] field_simp [show (k : ℚ) ≠ 0 by positivity] ring have hrD : (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) * (D : ℚ) = (N : ℚ) := by dsimp [N] push_cast rw [Finset.sum_mul] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro k hk calc ((-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) * (D : ℚ) = (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * ((1 / (k : ℚ)) * (D : ℚ)) := by ring _ = (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * ((D / k : ℕ) : ℚ) := by rw [hDkQ k hk] have hrat : (∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) = (p : ℚ) / (q : ℚ) := by have hcast : ((∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) : ℝ) = (((p : ℚ) / (q : ℚ)) : ℝ) := by calc ((∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) : ℝ) = ∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℝ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℝ)) := by push_cast rfl _ = (p : ℝ) / (q : ℝ) := h₁ _ = (((p : ℚ) / (q : ℚ)) : ℝ) := by push_cast rfl exact_mod_cast hcast have hq0 : (q : ℚ) ≠ 0 := by positivity have hpDqN : (p : ℚ) * (D : ℚ) = (q : ℚ) * (N : ℚ) := by calc (p : ℚ) * (D : ℚ) = (((p : ℚ) / (q : ℚ)) * (q : ℚ)) * (D : ℚ) := by field_simp [hq0] ring _ = ((∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) * (q : ℚ)) * (D : ℚ) := by rw [← hrat] _ = (q : ℚ) * ((∑ k ∈ Finset.Icc (1 : ℕ) 1319, (-1 : ℚ) ^ (k + 1) * (1 / (k : ℚ))) * (D : ℚ)) := by ring _ = (q : ℚ) * (N : ℚ) := by rw [hrD] have hpDqN_int : (p : ℤ) * (D : ℤ) = (q : ℤ) * N := by exact_mod_cast hpDqN have hdvdN : (1979 : ℤ) ∣ N := by rw [← ZMod.intCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] exact hNmod have hmodp : (1979 : ℤ) ∣ (p : ℤ) * (D : ℤ) := by rw [hpDqN_int] exact dvd_mul_of_dvd_right hdvdN (q : ℤ) have hDnotdvd : ¬ (1979 ∣ D) := by intro hdiv apply hDmod exact (ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd).mpr hdiv have hpdvd : 1979 ∣ p * D := by rw [← Int.natCast_dvd_natCast] push_cast exact hmodp have hprime_nat : Nat.Prime 1979 := hprime_fact.out rcases (Nat.Prime.dvd_mul hprime_nat).mp hpdvd with hp | hD · exact hp · exact False.elim (hDnotdvd hD) ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: none. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 6. `imo_1984_p6` (number_theory, hard) ### Problem (informal) Let $a,b,c,d$ be odd integers such that $01\). Hence \[ d-c=c\left(\frac ba-1\right)=\frac{c(b-a)}a>b-a, \] because \(c>a\). Therefore \(a+d>b+c\), so \(2^k>2^m\), and hence \(k>m\). Also \(m\ge 3\): indeed \(a,b,c\) are positive odd integers with \(0m\), the congruence \(a+d=2^k\) gives \[ d\equiv -a \pmod{2^m}, \] and \(b+c=2^m\) gives \[ c\equiv -b \pmod{2^m}. \] Using \(ad=bc\), we obtain \[ -a^2\equiv -b^2 \pmod{2^m}, \] so \[ a^2\equiv b^2 \pmod{2^m}. \] We now use a standard fact: if \(x,y\) are odd and \(m\ge 3\), then from \(x^2\equiv y^2\pmod{2^m}\) it follows that \(x\equiv \pm y\pmod{2^{m-1}}\). Indeed, \[ x^2-y^2=(x-y)(x+y), \] and for odd \(x,y\), one of \(x-y,x+y\) is divisible by exactly one factor of \(2\), so the other must be divisible by \(2^{m-1}\). Applying this to \(a,b\), we get \[ b\equiv \pm a \pmod{2^{m-1}}. \] Since \(bLean tactics tried in attempt 2 ```lean exact imo_1984_p6 a b c d k m h₀ h₁ h₂ h₃ h₄ h₅ ``` **Attempt 3:** `sanitize:empty` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages **Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: none. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 7. `imo_1987_p6` (number_theory, hard) ### Problem (informal) Let $n $ be an integer greater than or equal to 2. Prove that if $k^2 + k + n $ is prime for all integers $k $ such that $ 0 \leq k \leq \sqrt{n/3} $, then $k^2 + k + n $ is prime for all integers $k $ such that $0 \leq k \leq n - 2 $. ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem imo_1987_p6 (p : ℕ) (f : ℕ → ℕ) (h₀ : ∀ x, f x = x ^ 2 + x + p) (h₀ : ∀ k : ℕ, k ≤ Nat.floor (Real.sqrt (p / 3)) → Nat.Prime (f k)) : ∀ i ≤ p - 2, Nat.Prime (f i) := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Let f(x)=x^2+x+n. We prove the contrapositive. Suppose there is an integer k with 0≤k≤n−2 such that f(k) is composite, and choose the least such k. Since 0≤√(n/3), the hypothesis gives f(0)=n prime, so k≥1. Let q be the smallest prime divisor of f(k). Because f(k) is composite, q≤√(f(k)). We first show q>k. If q≤k, then k−q≥0, and f(k−q)=f(k)−q(2k−q+1), so q divides f(k−q). Also f(k−q)≥n≥k+2>q, since k≤n−2 and q≤k. Hence f(k−q) is composite and k−qk. Set r=q−k−1. Then r≥0. Since f(−k−1)=f(k) and r≡−k−1 (mod q), we have q|f(r). We claim r≥k. Suppose instead r0, using n≥k+2. A prime q cannot divide the product of two positive integers each smaller than q, contradiction. Hence r≥k. Therefore q=r+k+1≥2k+1. Since q≤√(f(k)), we obtain (2k+1)^2≤q^2≤f(k)=k^2+k+n. Thus 4k^2+4k+1≤k^2+k+n, so n≥3k^2+3k+1>3k^2. Hence k<√(n/3). By the hypothesis, f(k) must be prime, contradicting the choice of k as a composite value. This contradiction shows that no such k exists. Therefore f(k)=k^2+k+n is prime for every integer k with 0≤k≤n−2. **Final answer:** If k^2+k+n is prime for all 0≤k≤√(n/3), then k^2+k+n is prime for all 0≤k≤n−2. **C2's self-assessment:** verdict `correct`, confidence 0.99; no issues noted (1 round(s)). ### Lean check attempts **Attempt 1:** `lean:error` (class `missing_lemma`) ```text line 63: Unknown constant `ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd` line 79: Unknown constant `ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd` line 88: Invalid field `dvd_prime_iff_eq`: The environment does not contain `Irreducible.dvd_prime_iff_eq`, so it is not possible to project the field `dvd_prime_iff_eq` from an expression hq_prime of type `Irreducible q` ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean intro i hi by_contra hprime have hf : ∀ x, f x = x ^ 2 + x + p := by assumption have hp : ∀ k, k ≤ Nat.floor (Real.sqrt (p / 3)) → Nat.Prime (f k) := by assumption let P : ℕ → Prop := fun n => n ≤ p - 2 ∧ ¬ Nat.Prime (f n) have hex : ∃ n, P n := ⟨i, hi, hprime⟩ set k := Nat.find hex with hk_def have hkP : P k := by rw [hk_def] exact Nat.find_spec hex have hk_le : k ≤ p - 2 := hkP.1 have hk_not : ¬ Nat.Prime (f k) := hkP.2 have hk_min : ∀ j < k, ¬ P j := by intro j hj rw [hk_def] at hj exact Nat.find_min hex hj have hk_min_prime : ∀ j < k, j ≤ p - 2 → Nat.Prime (f j) := by intro j hj hle by_contra hjp exact hk_min j hj ⟨hle, hjp⟩ have hk_pos : 0 < k := by rcases Nat.eq_zero_or_pos k with hk0 | hkpos · exfalso have hprime0 : Nat.Prime (f 0) := hp 0 (Nat.zero_le _) exact hk_not (by simpa [hk0] using hprime0) · exact hkpos have hp0 : Nat.Prime p := by have h := hp 0 (Nat.zero_le _) have hf0 : f 0 = p := by simpa using hf 0 simpa [hf0] using h have hp_ge2 : 2 ≤ p := hp0.two_le have hfk_ge2 : 2 ≤ f k := by rw [hf k] have hk2 : 0 ≤ k ^ 2 := Nat.zero_le _ omega have h_exists_div : ∃ m, 2 ≤ m ∧ m ≤ Nat.sqrt (f k) ∧ m ∣ f k := by by_contra hno push_neg at hno have hprimefk : Nat.Prime (f k) := by rw [Nat.prime_def_le_sqrt] refine ⟨hfk_ge2, ?_⟩ intro m hm1 hm2 hm3 exact hno m hm1 hm2 hm3 exact hk_not hprimefk obtain ⟨m, hm_ge2, hm_le_sqrt, hm_dvd⟩ := h_exists_div have hm_ne_one : m ≠ 1 := by omega obtain ⟨q, hq_prime, hq_dvd_m⟩ := Nat.exists_prime_and_dvd hm_ne_one have hq_dvd : q ∣ f k := dvd_trans hq_dvd_m hm_dvd have hm_pos : 0 < m := by omega have hq_le_m : q ≤ m := Nat.le_of_dvd hm_pos hq_dvd_m have hq_le_sqrt : q ≤ Nat.sqrt (f k) := le_trans hq_le_m hm_le_sqrt have hq_pos : 0 < q := hq_prime.pos have hfk_mod : (f k : ZMod q) = 0 := by exact (ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd (f k) q).mpr hq_dvd have hq_gt_k : k < q := by by_contra hcon have hq_le_k : q ≤ k := by omega have hfkq_mod : (f (k - q) : ZMod q) = 0 := by have hkq_cast : ((k - q : ℕ) : ZMod q) = (k : ZMod q) := by rw [Nat.cast_sub hq_le_k] simp calc (f (k - q) : ZMod q) = (((k - q) ^ 2 + (k - q) + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by rw [hf (k - q)] _ = ((k - q : ℕ) : ZMod q) ^ 2 + ((k - q : ℕ) : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (k : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (k : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by rw [hkq_cast] _ = ((k ^ 2 + k + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (f k : ZMod q) := by rw [hf k] _ = 0 := hfk_mod have hq_dvd_fkq : q ∣ f (k - q) := by exact (ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd (f (k - q)) q).mp hfkq_mod have hkp2 : k + 2 ≤ p := by omega have hpq : q < p := by omega have hfkq_gt_q : q < f (k - q) := by rw [hf (k - q)] have hnonneg : 0 ≤ (k - q) ^ 2 + (k - q) := by positivity nlinarith have hfkq_not_prime : ¬ Nat.Prime (f (k - q)) := by intro hprime have hq_eq : q = f (k - q) := (hq_prime.dvd_prime_iff_eq hprime).mp hq_dvd_fkq omega have hkq_lt : k - q < k := by omega have hkq_le : k - q ≤ p - 2 := by omega have hprimefkq : Nat.Prime (f (k - q)) := hk_min_prime (k - q) hkq_lt hkq_le exact hfkq_not_prime hprimefkq set r := q - k - 1 with hr_def have hq_eq_r : q = r + k + 1 := by rw [hr_def] omega have hr_cast : ((r : ℕ) : ZMod q) = -((k : ZMod q) + 1) := by have hrq : r + k + 1 = q := hq_eq_r.symm have hzero : ((r + k + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod q) = 0 := by rw [hrq] simp push_cast at hzero linear_combination hzero have hfr_mod : (f r : ZMod q) = 0 := by calc (f r : ZMod q) = (((r) ^ 2 + r + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by rw [hf r] _ = (r : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (r : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (-((k : ZMod q) + 1)) ^ 2 + (-((k : ZMod q) + 1)) + (p : ZMod q) := by rw [hr_cast] _ = (k : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (k : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by ring _ = ((k ^ 2 + k + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (f k : ZMod q) := by rw [hf k] _ = 0 := hfk_mod have hq_dvd_fr : q ∣ f r := by exact (ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd (f r) q).mp hfr_mod have hr_ge_k : k ≤ r := by by_contra hcon have hr_lt : r < k := by omega have hr_prime : Nat.Prime (f r) := hk_min_prime r hr_lt (by omega) have hq_eq_fr : q = f r := (hq_prime.dvd_prime_iff_eq hr_prime).mp hq_dvd_fr have hprod_mod : (((k - r) * (k + r + 1) : ℕ) : ZMod q) = 0 := by have hkr : r ≤ k := le_of_lt hr_lt have hk_sub : ((k - r : ℕ) : ZMod q) = (k : ZMod q) - (r : ZMod q) := by rw [Nat.cast_sub hkr] calc (((k - r) * (k + r + 1) : ℕ) : ZMod q) = ((k - r : ℕ) : ZMod q) * ((k + r + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = ((k : ZMod q) - (r : ZMod q)) * ((k : ZMod q) + (r : ZMod q) + 1) := by rw [hk_sub] push_cast _ = ((k : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (k : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q)) - ((r : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (r : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q)) := by ring _ = (f k : ZMod q) - (f r : ZMod q) := by rw [hf k, hf r] push_cast ring _ = 0 := by rw [hfk_mod, hfr_mod]; simp have hq_dvd_prod : q ∣ (k - r) * (k + r + 1) := by exact (ZMod.natCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd ((k - r) * (k + r + 1)) q).mp hprod_mod have hq_dvd_or : q ∣ (k - r) ∨ q ∣ (k + r + 1) := (hq_prime.dvd_mul).mp hq_dvd_prod have hkr_pos : 0 < k - r := by omega have hkr_lt_q : k - r < q := by omega have hkr1_pos : 0 < k + r + 1 := by omega have hkr1_lt_q : k + r + 1 < q := by rw [hq_eq_fr, hf r] have hkp2 : k + 2 ≤ p := by omega have hr2 : 0 ≤ r ^ 2 := Nat.zero_le _ nlinarith rcases hq_dvd_or with h | h · have hle : q ≤ k - r := Nat.le_of_dvd hkr_pos h omega · have hle : q ≤ k + r + 1 := Nat.le_of_dvd hkr1_pos h omega have hq_ge : 2 * k + 1 ≤ q := by rw [hq_eq_r] omega have hq_sq_le : q ^ 2 ≤ f k := by have := hq_le_sqrt rwa [Nat.le_sqrt] at this have hineq : (2 * k + 1) ^ 2 ≤ f k := by have hsq : (2 * k + 1) ^ 2 ≤ q ^ 2 := by nlinarith [hq_ge, Nat.zero_le (2 * k + 1), Nat.zero_le q] exact le_trans hsq hq_sq_le have hp_gt : 3 * k ^ 2 < p := by rw [hf k] at hineq nlinarith have hk_le_floor : k ≤ Nat.floor (Real.sqrt (p / 3)) := by apply Nat.le_floor.mpr have hp_gtR : (3 : ℝ) * (k : ℝ) ^ 2 < (p : ℝ) := by exact_mod_cast hp_gt have hk_sq_le : (k : ℝ) ^ 2 ≤ (p : ℝ) / 3 := by nlinarith calc (k : ℝ) = Real.sqrt ((k : ℝ) ^ 2) := by rw [Real.sqrt_sq (by positivity)] _ ≤ Real.sqrt ((p : ℝ) / 3) := Real.sqrt_le_sqrt hk_sq_le exact hk_not (hp k hk_le_floor) ```
**Attempt 2:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 102: omega could not prove the goal: a possible counterexample may satisfy the constraints j ≥ 0 j ≤ 0 h ≥ 0 h - j ≥ 0 g ≥ 2 g - h ≤ 0 g - j ≥ 0 e ≥ 2 d ≥ 2 d - j ≥ 1 c ≥ 1 c - d ≤ -2 c - j ≥ 0 b ≥ 0 b - d ≤ -2 a ≥ 0 a - d ≤ -2 where a := ↑i b := ↑hex.choose c := ↑(Na line 103: Application type mismatch: The argument hq_dvd_fkq has type q ∣ f (k - q) but is expected to have type f (k - q) ∣ q in the application (Prime.dvd_iff_eq hq_prime hne1).mp hq_dvd_fkq line 105: omega could not prove the goal: a possible counterexample may satisfy the constraints l ≥ 0 j ≥ 0 h ≥ 0 h - j ≤ -1 h ≤ 0 h + l ≥ 1 g ≥ 0 g - h ≥ 0 e ≥ 2 e - g ≤ 0 e - h ≥ 0 d ≥ 2 c ≥ 2 c - h ≥ 1 c - h - l ≥ 2 b ≥ 0 b - c ≤ -2 a ≥ 0 a - c ≤ -2 where a := ↑i b : ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 2 ```lean intro i hi by_contra hprime have hf : ∀ x, f x = x ^ 2 + x + p := by assumption have hp : ∀ k, k ≤ Nat.floor (Real.sqrt (p / 3)) → Nat.Prime (f k) := by assumption let P : ℕ → Prop := fun n => n ≤ p - 2 ∧ ¬ Nat.Prime (f n) have hex : ∃ n, P n := ⟨i, hi, hprime⟩ set k := Nat.find hex with hk_def have hkP : P k := by rw [hk_def] exact Nat.find_spec hex have hk_le : k ≤ p - 2 := hkP.1 have hk_not : ¬ Nat.Prime (f k) := hkP.2 have hk_min : ∀ j < k, ¬ P j := by intro j hj rw [hk_def] at hj exact Nat.find_min hex hj have hk_min_prime : ∀ j < k, j ≤ p - 2 → Nat.Prime (f j) := by intro j hj hle by_contra hjp exact hk_min j hj ⟨hle, hjp⟩ have hk_pos : 0 < k := by rcases Nat.eq_zero_or_pos k with hk0 | hkpos · exfalso have hprime0 : Nat.Prime (f 0) := hp 0 (Nat.zero_le _) exact hk_not (by simpa [hk0] using hprime0) · exact hkpos have hp0 : Nat.Prime p := by have h := hp 0 (Nat.zero_le _) have hf0 : f 0 = p := by simpa using hf 0 simpa [hf0] using h have hp_ge2 : 2 ≤ p := hp0.two_le have hfk_ge2 : 2 ≤ f k := by rw [hf k] have hk2 : 0 ≤ k ^ 2 := Nat.zero_le _ omega have h_exists_div : ∃ m, 2 ≤ m ∧ m ≤ Nat.sqrt (f k) ∧ m ∣ f k := by by_contra hno push_neg at hno have hprimefk : Nat.Prime (f k) := by rw [Nat.prime_def_le_sqrt] refine ⟨hfk_ge2, ?_⟩ intro m hm1 hm2 hm3 exact hno m hm1 hm2 hm3 exact hk_not hprimefk obtain ⟨m, hm_ge2, hm_le_sqrt, hm_dvd⟩ := h_exists_div have hm_ne_one : m ≠ 1 := by omega obtain ⟨q, hq_prime, hq_dvd_m⟩ := Nat.exists_prime_and_dvd hm_ne_one have hq_dvd : q ∣ f k := dvd_trans hq_dvd_m hm_dvd have hm_pos : 0 < m := by omega have hq_le_m : q ≤ m := Nat.le_of_dvd hm_pos hq_dvd_m have hq_le_sqrt : q ≤ Nat.sqrt (f k) := le_trans hq_le_m hm_le_sqrt have hzmod_natCast_eq_zero_iff_dvd : ∀ n : ℕ, (n : ZMod q) = 0 ↔ q ∣ n := by intro n constructor · intro h have h' : ((n : ℤ) : ZMod q) = 0 := by push_cast exact h rw [ZMod.intCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] at h' exact_mod_cast h' · intro h have h' : ((n : ℤ) : ZMod q) = 0 := by rw [ZMod.intCast_zmod_eq_zero_iff_dvd] exact_mod_cast h push_cast at h' exact h' have hfk_mod : (f k : ZMod q) = 0 := by exact (hzmod_natCast_eq_zero_iff_dvd (f k)).mpr hq_dvd have hq_gt_k : k < q := by by_contra hcon have hq_le_k : q ≤ k := by omega have hfkq_mod : (f (k - q) : ZMod q) = 0 := by have hkq_cast : ((k - q : ℕ) : ZMod q) = (k : ZMod q) := by rw [Nat.cast_sub hq_le_k] simp calc (f (k - q) : ZMod q) = (((k - q) ^ 2 + (k - q) + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by rw [hf (k - q)] _ = ((k - q : ℕ) : ZMod q) ^ 2 + ((k - q : ℕ) : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (k : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (k : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by rw [hkq_cast] _ = ((k ^ 2 + k + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (f k : ZMod q) := by rw [hf k] _ = 0 := hfk_mod have hq_dvd_fkq : q ∣ f (k - q) := by exact (hzmod_natCast_eq_zero_iff_dvd (f (k - q))).mp hfkq_mod have hkp2 : k + 2 ≤ p := by omega have hpq : q < p := by omega have hfkq_gt_q : q < f (k - q) := by rw [hf (k - q)] have hnonneg : 0 ≤ (k - q) ^ 2 + (k - q) := by positivity nlinarith have hfkq_not_prime : ¬ Nat.Prime (f (k - q)) := by intro hprime have hne1 : f (k - q) ≠ 1 := by omega have hq_eq : q = f (k - q) := (Nat.Prime.dvd_iff_eq hq_prime hne1).mp hq_dvd_fkq omega have hkq_lt : k - q < k := by omega have hkq_le : k - q ≤ p - 2 := by omega have hprimefkq : Nat.Prime (f (k - q)) := hk_min_prime (k - q) hkq_lt hkq_le exact hfkq_not_prime hprimefkq set r := q - k - 1 with hr_def have hq_eq_r : q = r + k + 1 := by rw [hr_def] omega have hr_cast : ((r : ℕ) : ZMod q) = -((k : ZMod q) + 1) := by have hrq : r + k + 1 = q := hq_eq_r.symm have hzero : ((r + k + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod q) = 0 := by rw [hrq] simp push_cast at hzero linear_combination hzero have hfr_mod : (f r : ZMod q) = 0 := by calc (f r : ZMod q) = (((r) ^ 2 + r + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by rw [hf r] _ = (r : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (r : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (-((k : ZMod q) + 1)) ^ 2 + (-((k : ZMod q) + 1)) + (p : ZMod q) := by rw [hr_cast] _ = (k : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (k : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q) := by ring _ = ((k ^ 2 + k + p : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = (f k : ZMod q) := by rw [hf k] _ = 0 := hfk_mod have hq_dvd_fr : q ∣ f r := by exact (hzmod_natCast_eq_zero_iff_dvd (f r)).mp hfr_mod have hr_ge_k : k ≤ r := by by_contra hcon have hr_lt : r < k := by omega have hr_prime : Nat.Prime (f r) := hk_min_prime r hr_lt (by omega) have hfr_ne1 : f r ≠ 1 := by rw [hf r] have h1 : 0 ≤ r ^ 2 := Nat.zero_le _ omega have hq_eq_fr : q = f r := (Nat.Prime.dvd_iff_eq hq_prime hfr_ne1).mp hq_dvd_fr have hprod_mod : (((k - r) * (k + r + 1) : ℕ) : ZMod q) = 0 := by have hkr : r ≤ k := le_of_lt hr_lt have hk_sub : ((k - r : ℕ) : ZMod q) = (k : ZMod q) - (r : ZMod q) := by rw [Nat.cast_sub hkr] calc (((k - r) * (k + r + 1) : ℕ) : ZMod q) = ((k - r : ℕ) : ZMod q) * ((k + r + 1 : ℕ) : ZMod q) := by push_cast; ring _ = ((k : ZMod q) - (r : ZMod q)) * ((k : ZMod q) + (r : ZMod q) + 1) := by rw [hk_sub] push_cast _ = ((k : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (k : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q)) - ((r : ZMod q) ^ 2 + (r : ZMod q) + (p : ZMod q)) := by ring _ = (f k : ZMod q) - (f r : ZMod q) := by rw [hf k, hf r] push_cast ring _ = 0 := by rw [hfk_mod, hfr_mod]; simp have hq_dvd_prod : q ∣ (k - r) * (k + r + 1) := by exact (hzmod_natCast_eq_zero_iff_dvd ((k - r) * (k + r + 1))).mp hprod_mod have hq_dvd_or : q ∣ (k - r) ∨ q ∣ (k + r + 1) := (hq_prime.dvd_mul).mp hq_dvd_prod have hkr_pos : 0 < k - r := by omega have hkr_lt_q : k - r < q := by omega have hkr1_pos : 0 < k + r + 1 := by omega have hkr1_lt_q : k + r + 1 < q := by rw [hq_eq_fr, hf r] have hkp2 : k + 2 ≤ p := by omega have hr2 : 0 ≤ r ^ 2 := Nat.zero_le _ nlinarith rcases hq_dvd_or with h | h · have hle : q ≤ k - r := Nat.le_of_dvd hkr_pos h omega · have hle : q ≤ k + r + 1 := Nat.le_of_dvd hkr1_pos h omega have hq_ge : 2 * k + 1 ≤ q := by rw [hq_eq_r] omega have hq_sq_le : q ^ 2 ≤ f k := by have := hq_le_sqrt rwa [Nat.le_sqrt] at this have hineq : (2 * k + 1) ^ 2 ≤ f k := by have hsq : (2 * k + 1) ^ 2 ≤ q ^ 2 := by nlinarith [hq_ge, Nat.zero_le (2 * k + 1), Nat.zero_le q] exact le_trans hsq hq_sq_le have hp_gt : 3 * k ^ 2 < p := by rw [hf k] at hineq nlinarith have hk_le_floor : k ≤ Nat.floor (Real.sqrt (p / 3)) := by apply Nat.le_floor.mpr have hp_gtR : (3 : ℝ) * (k : ℝ) ^ 2 < (p : ℝ) := by exact_mod_cast hp_gt have hk_sq_le : (k : ℝ) ^ 2 ≤ (p : ℝ) / 3 := by nlinarith calc (k : ℝ) = Real.sqrt ((k : ℝ) ^ 2) := by rw [Real.sqrt_sq (by positivity)] _ ≤ Real.sqrt ((p : ℝ) / 3) := Real.sqrt_le_sqrt hk_sq_le exact hk_not (hp k hk_le_floor) ```
**Attempt 3:** `sanitize:syntax` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean intro i hi by_contra hprime have hf : ∀ x, f x = x ^ 2 + x + p := by assumption have hp : ∀ k, k ≤ Nat.floor (Real.sqrt (p / 3)) → Nat.Prime (f k) := by assumption let P : ℕ → Prop := fun n => n ≤ p - 2 ∧ ¬ Nat.Prime (f n) have hex : ∃ n, P n := ⟨i, hi, hprime⟩ set k := Nat.find hex with hk_def have hkP : P k := by rw [hk_def] exact Nat.find_spec hex have hk_le : k ≤ p - 2 := hkP.1 have hk_not : ¬ Nat.Prime (f k) := hkP.2 have hk_min : ∀ j < k, ¬ P j := by intro j hj rw [hk_def] at hj exact Nat.find_min hex hj have hk_min_prime : ∀ j < k, j ≤ p - 2 → Nat.Prime (f j) := by intro j hj hle by_contra hjp exact hk_min j hj ⟨hle, hjp⟩ have hk_pos : 0 < k := by rcases Nat.eq_zero_or_pos k with hk0 | hkpos · exfalso have hprime0 : Nat.Prime (f 0) := hp 0 (Nat.zero_le _) exact hk_not (by simpa [hk0] using hprime0) · exact hkpos have hp0 : Nat.Prime p := by have h := hp 0 (Nat.zero_le _) have hf0 : f 0 = p := by simpa using hf 0 simpa [hf0] using h have hp_ge2 : 2 ≤ p := hp0.two_le have hkp2 : k + 2 ≤ p := by have h := Nat.add_le_add_right hk_le 2 simpa [Nat.sub_add_cancel hp_ge2] using h have hk_lt_p : k < p := by omega have hfk_ge2 : 2 ≤ f k := by rw [hf k] have hk2 : 0 ≤ k ^ 2 := Nat.zero_le _ omega have h_exists_div : ∃ m, 2 ≤ m ∧ m ≤ Nat.sqrt (f k) ∧ m ∣ f k := by by_contra hno push_neg at hno have hprimefk : Nat.Prime (f k) := by rw [Nat.prime_def_le_sqrt] refine ⟨hfk_ge2, ?_⟩ intro m hm1 hm2 hm3 exact hno m hm1 hm2 hm3 exact hk_not hprimefk obtain ⟨m, hm_ge2, hm_le_sqrt, hm_dvd⟩ := h_exists_div have hm_ne_one : m ≠ 1 := by omega obtain ⟨q, hq_prime, hq_dvd_m⟩ := Nat.exists_prime_and_dvd hm_ne_one have hq_dvd : q ∣ f k := dvd_trans hq_dvd_m hm_dvd have hm ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: none. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 8. `imo_1993_p5` (algebra, hard) ### Problem (informal) Let $\mathbb{N} = \{1,2,3, \ldots\}$. Determine if there exists a strictly increasing function $f: \mathbb{N} \mapsto \mathbb{N}$ with the following properties: (i) $f(1) = 2$; (ii) $f(f(n)) = f(n) + n, (n \in \mathbb{N})$. ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem imo_1993_p5 : ∃ f : ℕ → ℕ, f 1 = 2 ∧ ∀ n, f (f n) = f n + n ∧ ∀ n, f n < f (n + 1) := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Yes, such a function exists. Let \[ \varphi=\frac{1+\sqrt5}{2}, \] so that \varphi^2=\varphi+1 and \varphi-1=1/\varphi. Define \[ f(n)=\left\lfloor \varphi n+\frac12\right\rfloor \qquad(n\in\mathbb N). \] First, \[ f(1)=\left\lfloor \varphi+\frac12\right\rfloor=2, \] since \varphi=1.618\ldots, so \varphi+1/2\in(2,3). Next, f is strictly increasing. For any n, write y=\varphi n+1/2. Since \varphi>1, we have y+\varphi>y+1, hence \[ \left\lfloor y+\varphi\right\rfloor\ge \left\lfloor y\right\rfloor+1. \] Therefore \[ f(n+1)=\left\lfloor \varphi(n+1)+\frac12\right\rfloor \ge \left\lfloor \varphi n+\frac12\right\rfloor+1=f(n)+1, \] so f is strictly increasing. It remains to prove the identity. Fix n\in\mathbb N and set m=f(n). Then m is the nearest integer to \varphi n, so \[ m-\frac12<\varphi nLean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean have hsqrt_gt2 : (2 : ℝ) < Real.sqrt 5 := by exact (Real.lt_sqrt (by norm_num : (0 : ℝ) ≤ 2)).mpr (by norm_num) have hsqrt_lt3 : Real.sqrt 5 < 3 := by nlinarith [Real.sq_sqrt (show (0 : ℝ) ≤ 5 by norm_num), Real.sqrt_nonneg 5, sq_nonneg (Real.sqrt 5 - 3)] let φ : ℝ := (1 + Real.sqrt 5) / 2 let f : ℕ → ℕ := fun n => Nat.floor (φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2) have hφ_sq : φ ^ 2 = φ + 1 := by have hsq : (Real.sqrt 5) ^ 2 = 5 := Real.sq_sqrt (by norm_num) dsimp [φ] nlinarith [hsq] have hφ_gt1 : 1 < φ := by dsimp [φ] linarith [hsqrt_gt2] have hφ_lt2 : φ < 2 := by dsimp [φ] linarith [hsqrt_lt3] have hφpos : 0 < φ := lt_trans zero_lt_one hφ_gt1 refine ⟨f, ?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · dsimp [f] have hxpos : (0 : ℝ) ≤ φ * (1 : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by nlinarith [hφpos] rw [Nat.floor_eq_iff hxpos] constructor · dsimp [φ] linarith [hsqrt_gt2] · linarith [hφ_lt2] · intro n have hfloor_le : (f n : ℝ) ≤ φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by dsimp [f] apply Nat.floor_le have hnnonneg : (0 : ℝ) ≤ n := by exact_mod_cast Nat.zero_le n nlinarith [mul_nonneg (le_of_lt hφpos) hnnonneg] have hlt : (f n : ℝ) + 1 < φ * ((n : ℝ) + 1) + 1 / 2 := by nlinarith [hfloor_le, hφ_gt1] have hle : f n + 1 ≤ f (n + 1) := by dsimp [f] apply Nat.le_floor exact_mod_cast le_of_lt hlt omega · intro n let m : ℕ := f n have hmlow : (m : ℝ) ≤ φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by dsimp [m, f] apply Nat.floor_le have hnnonneg : (0 : ℝ) ≤ n := by exact_mod_cast Nat.zero_le n nlinarith [mul_nonneg (le_of_lt hφpos) hnnonneg] have hmup : φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 < (m : ℝ) + 1 := by dsimp [m, f] exact Nat.lt_floor_add_one _ have hnum : 0 < (m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ) + φ / 2 := by nlinarith [hmup, hφ_gt1] have hDmul : φ * (φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2 - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ))) = (m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ) + φ / 2 := by nlinarith [hφ_sq] have hDpos : 0 < φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2 - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ)) := by have hmulpos : 0 < φ * (φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2 - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ))) := by rw [hDmul] exact hnum exact pos_of_mul_pos_left hmulpos (le_of_lt hφpos) have hnum_le : (m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ) + φ / 2 ≤ (1 + φ) / 2 := by linarith [hmlow] have hDlt1 : φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2 - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ)) < 1 := by have hmul_lt : φ * (φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2 - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ))) < φ * 1 := by rw [hDmul] nlinarith [hnum_le, hφ_gt1] exact (mul_lt_mul_left hφpos).mp hmul_lt have hfloor : Nat.floor (φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2) = m + n := by have hmnonneg : (0 : ℝ) ≤ m := by exact_mod_cast Nat.zero_le m have hxpos : (0 : ℝ) ≤ φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by nlinarith [mul_nonneg (le_of_lt hφpos) hmnonneg] rw [Nat.floor_eq_iff hxpos] constructor · push_cast linarith [hDpos] · push_cast linarith [hDlt1] simpa [f, m] using hfloor ``` **Attempt 2:** `sanitize:empty` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages **Attempt 3:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 10: Invalid pattern variable: Variable name must be atomic, but `Nat.totient._@.3120910823._hygCtx._hyg.95` has multiple components line 11: No goals to be solved ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean let φ : ℝ := (1 + Real.sqrt 5) / 2 have hsqrt5 : (Real.sqrt 5) ^ 2 = 5 := by rw [Real.sq_sqrt] norm_num have hsqrt5_gt2 : 2 < Real.sqrt 5 := by rw [Real.lt_sqrt (by norm_num)] norm_num have hsqrt5_lt3 : Real.sqrt 5 < 3 := by rw [Real.sqrt_lt (by norm_num)] norm_num have hφsq : φ ^ 2 = φ + 1 := by dsimp [φ] field_simp nlinarith [hsqrt5] have hφpos : 0 < φ := by dsimp [φ] positivity have hφ32 : (3 : ℝ) / 2 < φ := by dsimp [φ] nlinarith [hsqrt5_gt2] have hφ1 : 1 < φ := by linarith have hφ2 : φ < 2 := by dsimp [φ] nlinarith [hsqrt5_lt3] let f : ℕ → ℕ := fun n => Nat.floor (φ * n + 1 / 2) refine ⟨f, ?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · dsimp [f] exact (Nat.floor_eq_iff (by positivity)).2 ⟨by nlinarith [hφ32], by nlinarith [hφ2]⟩ · intro n dsimp [f] let m : ℕ := Nat.floor (φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2) have hmn_nonneg : 0 ≤ φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by positivity have hm_le : (m : ℝ) ≤ φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by dsimp [m] exact Nat.floor_le hmn_nonneg have hm_lt : φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 < (m : ℝ) + 1 := by dsimp [m] exact Nat.lt_floor_add_one _ have hd_le : (m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ) ≤ 1 / 2 := by linarith have hd_gt : -1 / 2 < (m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ) := by linarith have hmul : φ * (φ * (m : ℝ) - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ))) = (m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ) := by linear_combination (m : ℝ) * hφsq have hφne : φ ≠ 0 := ne_of_gt hφpos have he_eq : φ * (m : ℝ) - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ)) = ((m : ℝ) - φ * (n : ℝ)) / φ := by rw [eq_div_iff hφne] linarith [hmul] have hlower : -1 / 2 < φ * (m : ℝ) - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ)) := by rw [he_eq, lt_div_iff hφpos] nlinarith [hd_gt, hφ1] have hupper : φ * (m : ℝ) - ((m : ℝ) + (n : ℝ)) < 1 / 2 := by rw [he_eq, div_lt_iff hφpos] nlinarith [hd_le, hφ1] have hfloor : Nat.floor (φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2) = m + n := by exact (Nat.floor_eq_iff (by positivity)).2 ⟨by push_cast; linarith, by push_cast; linarith⟩ change Nat.floor (φ * (m : ℝ) + 1 / 2) = m + n exact hfloor · intro n dsimp [f] have hle : Nat.floor (φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2) + 1 ≤ Nat.floor (φ * (n + 1 : ℕ) + 1 / 2) := by apply (Nat.le_floor (by positivity)).2 have hfl : (Nat.floor (φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2) : ℝ) ≤ φ * (n : ℝ) + 1 / 2 := by exact Nat.floor_le (by positivity) push_cast nlinarith [hfl, hφ1] exact Nat.lt_of_succ_le hle ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: C3. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 9. `putnam_1965_b2` (combinatorics, hard) ### Problem (informal) [Informal statement not redistributed: PutnamBench states it is available with permission from the MAA. Problem: Putnam 1965 B2; source: PutnamBench informal/putnam.json, commit a635813f.] ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem putnam_1965_b2 (n : ℕ) (hn : n > 1) (won : Fin n → Fin n → Bool) (hirrefl : ∀ i : Fin n, won i i = false) (hantisymm : ∀ i j : Fin n, i ≠ j → won i j = ¬won j i) (w l : Fin n → ℤ) (hw : w = fun r : Fin n => ∑ j : Fin n, (if won r j then 1 else 0)) (hl : l = fun r : Fin n => n - 1 - w r) : ∑ r : Fin n, (w r)^2 = ∑ r : Fin n, (l r)^2 := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) In a round-robin tournament with n players, every player plays exactly n-1 games, so for each r, w_r + l_r = n-1. Also, each game produces exactly one win and exactly one loss. Therefore the total number of wins equals the total number of losses, and both equal the total number of games, namely n(n-1)/2. Hence ∑_{r=1}^n w_r = ∑_{r=1}^n l_r. Now compute the difference of the two desired sums: ∑_{r=1}^n w_r^2 - ∑_{r=1}^n l_r^2 = ∑_{r=1}^n (w_r^2 - l_r^2) = ∑_{r=1}^n (w_r-l_r)(w_r+l_r). Using w_r+l_r=n-1, this becomes ∑_{r=1}^n (w_r-l_r)(n-1) = (n-1)∑_{r=1}^n (w_r-l_r) = (n-1)\(∑_{r=1}^n w_r - ∑_{r=1}^n l_r\). Since ∑ w_r = ∑ l_r, the last expression is 0. Therefore ∑_{r=1}^n w_r^2 = ∑_{r=1}^n l_r^2. **Final answer:** For every round-robin tournament, \(\sum_{r=1}^{n} w_r^2 = \sum_{r=1}^{n} l_r^2\). **C2's self-assessment:** verdict `correct`, confidence 0.99; issues it noted: Minor typographical issue: there is a stray backslash before a parenthesis in the line involving (n-1)(sum w_r - sum l_r), but it does not affect the mathematical argument. (1 round(s)). ### Lean check attempts **Attempt 1:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 11: No goals to be solved ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 1 ```lean let f : Fin n → Fin n → ℤ := fun r j => if won r j then 1 else 0 have hw' : ∀ r : Fin n, w r = ∑ j : Fin n, f r j := by intro r rw [hw] simp [f] have hl' : ∀ r : Fin n, l r = (n : ℤ) - 1 - w r := by intro r simpa using congrFun hl r have hpoint : ∀ r j : Fin n, f r j + f j r = if r = j then 0 else 1 := by intro r j by_cases h : r = j · rw [h] simp [f, hirrefl] · rw [if_neg h] have hh := hantisymm r j h cases h1 : won r j <;> cases h2 : won j r <;> simp_all [f] have hinner : ∀ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, (f r j + f j r) = (n : ℤ) - 1 := by intro r calc ∑ j : Fin n, (f r j + f j r) = ∑ j : Fin n, (if r = j then (0 : ℤ) else 1) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j _ exact hpoint r j _ = ∑ j : Fin n, (1 - (if r = j then (1 : ℤ) else 0)) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j _ by_cases h : r = j <;> simp [h] _ = ∑ j : Fin n, (1 : ℤ) - ∑ j : Fin n, (if r = j then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib] _ = (n : ℤ) - 1 := by rw [Finset.sum_const, Finset.card_univ] rw [Finset.sum_ite_eq] simp [Finset.mem_univ] have hsumpt : ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, (f r j + f j r) = (n : ℤ) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by calc ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, (f r j + f j r) = ∑ r : Fin n, ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r _ exact hinner r _ = (n : ℤ) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by rw [Finset.sum_const, Finset.card_univ] simp [nsmul_eq_mul] have hswap : (∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f r j) = ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f j r := by simpa using (Finset.sum_comm : (∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f r j) = ∑ j : Fin n, ∑ r : Fin n, f r j) have hdouble : 2 * ∑ r : Fin n, w r = ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, (f r j + f j r) := by calc 2 * ∑ r : Fin n, w r = 2 * ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f r j := by congr 1 apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r _ exact hw' r _ = (∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f r j) + (∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f r j) := by ring _ = (∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f r j) + (∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, f j r) := by rw [hswap] _ = ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, (f r j + f j r) := by rw [← Finset.sum_add_distrib] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r _ rw [← Finset.sum_add_distrib] have hdouble2 : 2 * ∑ r : Fin n, w r = (n : ℤ) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by rw [hdouble, hsumpt] have hsum : ∑ r : Fin n, w r = ∑ r : Fin n, l r := by simp only [hl'] rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib] have hconst : ∑ r : Fin n, ((n : ℤ) - 1) = (n : ℤ) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by rw [Finset.sum_const, Finset.card_univ] simp [nsmul_eq_mul] rw [hconst] linarith [hdouble2] have hdiff : ∑ r : Fin n, ((w r)^2 - (l r)^2) = 0 := by calc ∑ r : Fin n, ((w r)^2 - (l r)^2) = ∑ r : Fin n, ((w r - l r) * (w r + l r)) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r _ ring _ = ∑ r : Fin n, ((w r - l r) * ((n : ℤ) - 1)) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r _ rw [hl' r] ring _ = ((n : ℤ) - 1) * ∑ r : Fin n, (w r - l r) := by rw [Finset.mul_sum] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r _ ring _ = ((n : ℤ) - 1) * (∑ r : Fin n, w r - ∑ r : Fin n, l r) := by rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib] _ = 0 := by rw [hsum] ring have hzero : ∑ r : Fin n, (w r)^2 - ∑ r : Fin n, (l r)^2 = 0 := by rw [← Finset.sum_sub_distrib] exact hdiff linarith ```
**Attempt 2:** `sanitize:empty` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages **Attempt 3:** `lean:error` (class `tactic_failure`) ```text line 33: Application type mismatch: The argument h has type ¬j = r but is expected to have type r ≠ j in the application hantisymm r j h ```
Lean tactics tried in attempt 3 ```lean have hl_eq : ∀ r : Fin n, l r = ∑ j : Fin n, (if won j r then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by intro r rw [hl, hw] have hsum_diag : ∑ j : Fin n, (if j = r then (0 : ℤ) else 1) = (n : ℤ) - 1 := by calc ∑ j : Fin n, (if j = r then (0 : ℤ) else 1) = ∑ j : Fin n, ((1 : ℤ) - (if j = r then (1 : ℤ) else 0)) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j hj by_cases h : j = r <;> simp [h] _ = ∑ j : Fin n, (1 : ℤ) - ∑ j : Fin n, (if j = r then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib] _ = (n : ℤ) - 1 := by simp [Finset.sum_ite_eq', Finset.card_univ] calc (n : ℤ) - 1 - ∑ j : Fin n, (if won r j then (1 : ℤ) else 0) = ∑ j : Fin n, (if j = r then (0 : ℤ) else 1) - ∑ j : Fin n, (if won r j then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by rw [hsum_diag] _ = ∑ j : Fin n, ((if j = r then (0 : ℤ) else 1) - (if won r j then (1 : ℤ) else 0)) := by rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib] _ = ∑ j : Fin n, (if won j r then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j hj by_cases h : j = r · rw [h] simp [hirrefl] · have hb := hantisymm r j h cases hwj : won j r <;> simp [h, hb, hwj] have hsum : ∑ r : Fin n, l r = ∑ r : Fin n, w r := by calc ∑ r : Fin n, l r = ∑ r : Fin n, ∑ j : Fin n, (if won j r then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r hr exact hl_eq r _ = ∑ j : Fin n, ∑ r : Fin n, (if won j r then (1 : ℤ) else 0) := by rw [Finset.sum_comm] _ = ∑ r : Fin n, w r := by simpa [hw] have hfac : ∀ r : Fin n, w r ^ 2 - l r ^ 2 = (w r - l r) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by intro r have hwl : w r + l r = (n : ℤ) - 1 := by rw [hl] ring calc w r ^ 2 - l r ^ 2 = (w r - l r) * (w r + l r) := by ring _ = (w r - l r) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by rw [hwl] have hmain : ∑ r : Fin n, (w r ^ 2 - l r ^ 2) = 0 := by calc ∑ r : Fin n, (w r ^ 2 - l r ^ 2) = ∑ r : Fin n, ((w r - l r) * ((n : ℤ) - 1)) := by apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro r hr exact hfac r _ = (∑ r : Fin n, (w r - l r)) * ((n : ℤ) - 1) := by rw [Finset.sum_mul] _ = 0 := by have hs : ∑ r : Fin n, (w r - l r) = 0 := by rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib, hsum] ring rw [hs] ring have hsub : ∑ r : Fin n, w r ^ 2 - ∑ r : Fin n, l r ^ 2 = 0 := by rw [← Finset.sum_sub_distrib] exact hmain exact sub_eq_zero.mp hsub ```
**Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: C1, C3, C5. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:** --- ## 10. `putnam_1995_b1` (combinatorics, hard) ### Problem (informal) [Informal statement not redistributed: PutnamBench states it is available with permission from the MAA. Problem: Putnam 1995 B1; source: PutnamBench informal/putnam.json, commit a635813f.] ### Formal statement (what Lean had to prove) ```lean theorem putnam_1995_b1 (Pi : Finpartition (Finset.range 9) → (Finset.range 9) → ℕ) (Pi_def : ∀ partition k, Pi partition k = (Exists.choose (Finpartition.exists_mem partition k.2)).card) : ∀ Pt1 Pt2, ∃ x y : Finset.range 9, x ≠ y ∧ Pi Pt1 x = Pi Pt1 y ∧ Pi Pt2 x = Pi Pt2 y := by ``` ### C2's solution (natural language) Proof. Let S={1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9}. For each x∈S, consider the ordered pair P(x)=(π(x),π'(x)). Suppose, for contradiction, that no two distinct elements have the same ordered pair. Then P is injective. Let R be the set of distinct part sizes occurring in π, and let C be the set of distinct part sizes occurring in π'. Then P(x)∈R×C for every x, so 9=|S|≤|R||C|. We claim |R|≤3. Indeed, if R contained four distinct positive integers, their sum would be at least 1+2+3+4=10, but the sum of all part sizes in π is 9, so this is impossible. Thus |R|≤3. Similarly, |C|≤3. Hence 9≤|R||C|≤9, so |R|=|C|=3 and P is a bijection from S onto R×C. Now fix a∈R. Let n_a be the number of parts of π of size a. The number of elements x with π(x)=a is a n_a, because these elements are exactly the union of those n_a parts. On the other hand, since P is a bijection onto R×C, for each b∈C there is exactly one x with P(x)=(a,b). Therefore exactly |C|=3 elements satisfy π(x)=a. Hence a n_a=3 for every a∈R. Thus every a∈R divides 3, so R⊆{1,3}; in particular |R|≤2, contradicting |R|=3. This contradiction shows that P is not injective. Therefore there exist distinct x,y∈S such that P(x)=P(y), i.e. π(x)=π(y) and π'(x)=π'(y). **Final answer:** For any two partitions π and π' of {1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9}, there exist distinct x,y such that π(x)=π(y) and π'(x)=π'(y). **C2's self-assessment:** verdict `correct`, confidence 1.0; no issues noted (1 round(s)). ### Lean check attempts **Attempt 1:** `sanitize:empty` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages **Attempt 2:** `sanitize:empty` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages **Attempt 3:** `sanitize:empty` (class `syntax`) — no Lean messages **Context:** formal statement proved by other configurations: none. ### Verdict - [ ] Wrong argument - [ ] Formalisation failure - [ ] Cannot decide **Reason:**